Salon Home
Matt Zoller Seitz
Saturday, Jan 7, 2012 12:30 AM UTC2012-01-07T00:30:00Zl, M j, Y g:i A T

Movies for a desert island

What if you could only watch the same 10 films and TV shows forever? Compare your list to these classics

SLIDE SHOW

You don’t need much of a setup for this one: It’s a Desert Island List of visual media that I’d like to have with me if I were shipwrecked.

Here are the rules:

1. This list is composed solely of motion pictures and TV shows. Music, books, paintings and other media are not included. It is assumed that you’ll have an indestructible DVD player with a solar-recharging power source, so let’s not get bogged down in refrigerator logic, mm’kay?

2. You can list 10 feature films, one short and a single, self-contained season of a TV series.

3. NO CHEATING. Every slot on the list must be claimed by a self-contained unit of media. You can put all 15 hours of “Berlin Alexanderplatz” on the list because it’s considered one long film (or if you saw it in Germany, a TV miniseries), but you can’t put “The Godfather” and “The Godfather, Part II” in the same slot because “it counts as one long film” (it doesn’t!). You can’t put 10 seasons of “I Love Lucy” on their, either, or “‘Twin Peaks’ up through the part in Season 2 where we finally find out who killed Laura Palmer.” Part of the fun of this exercise is figuring out what you think you can watch over and over, and what you can live without. Stick to the parameters, otherwise we’ll have human sacrifice, dogs and cats living together, and mass hysteria.

I’ve listed my short film pick and my TV season first, followed by a list of 10 theatrical features in alphabetical order. Please add your own picks to the Letters section; I want to see what you’d put in your suitcase.

View the slide show

Saturday, Dec 31, 2011 1:00 AM UTC2011-12-31T01:00:00Zl, M j, Y g:i A T

2011′s best TV episodes

It's easy to rank the year's best shows. But what were the individual episodes you need to see?

SLIDE SHOW
seitz week2

 (Credit: Monkik via Shutterstock/Salon)

View the slide show

This is the top half of my year-end list of the 20 best individual episodes of scripted TV dramas and comedies. This slide show covers items 10 through 1. To read 20 through 11, which ran last week, click here.

View the slide show

Tuesday, Dec 27, 2011 1:00 AM UTC2011-12-27T01:00:00Zl, M j, Y g:i A T

Nostalgic for everything

From "Midnight in Paris" to "The Artist" to "Mildred Pierce," in 2011 we wanted to be anywhere but 2011

VIDEO
Stills from "Midnight in Paris," "Super 8" and "The Tree of Life"

Stills from "Midnight in Paris," "Super 8" and "The Tree of Life"

“Nostalgia is denial — denial of the painful present,” says a philosopher (Michael Sheen) in Woody Allen’s surprise hit “Midnight in Paris.” “The name for this denial is Golden Age thinking: the erroneous notion that a different time period is better than the one [that] one’s living in. It’s a flaw in the romantic imagination of those people who find it difficult to cope with the present.”

If nostalgia is indeed a flaw, it’s one that many 2011 films and TV programs shared. Some of the year’s most talked-about movies and shows gave themselves over to some form of nostalgia — unabashedly reveling in, and idealizing, not just an earlier time, but the artists and artistic styles that we associate with that time, and the rush of emotion that accompanies our fantasies of same. Allen’s “Midnight in Paris” — his top grossing movie ever — is Exhibit A. It’s an immensely likable reworking of his short story “A Twenties Memory” in which an Allen stand-in, screenwriter Gil (Owen Wilson), magically gets to travel back to the time of Ernest Hemingway and Gertrude Stein. But it’s merely the keynote address in a year of budget-busting, production-design-showcasing, time-tripping cinema and television, a year that invited viewers not merely to experience stories from another time but to slip into them with deep pleasure and savor their restorative power.

Continue Reading
Saturday, Dec 24, 2011 1:00 AM UTC2011-12-24T01:00:00Zl, M j, Y g:i A T

TV’s best episodes in 2011

Set your DVR: In the first of a two-part slide show, we count down the top 20 specific shows of the last year

SLIDE SHOW
seitz week1

 (Credit: Monkik via Shutterstock/Salon)

View the slide show

If most sports is a game of inches, most TV is a game of episodes. That’s why, at year’s end, I always feel a bit weird compiling a list of the year’s best series: Even a great series can have a bad episode, or a string of them, and even inconsistent or mostly mediocre series can produce memorable, even great installments.

Back in 2005, when I was a TV critic for the Newark Star-Ledger, I started publishing a yearly list of the best individual episodes of scripted TV shows. I’m continuing that tradition here at Salon with a citation of my 20 favorite episodes of scripted comedies and dramas.

For suspense’s sake, we’re breaking my 2011 list into two installments. This week’s covers items 20 through 11 on my list; next Friday we’ll count down the top 10.

View the slide show

Thursday, Dec 22, 2011 9:40 PM UTC2011-12-22T21:40:00Zl, M j, Y g:i A T

The best nonfiction TV of 2011

Forget "Real Housewives." From portraits of cultural masters to scary Occupy tales, these shows captured reality

VIDEO
An Occupy Wall Street protester draws contact from a police officer near Zuccotti Park after being ordered to leave the longtime encampment in New York, Nov. 15, 2011

An Occupy Wall Street protester draws contact from a police officer near Zuccotti Park after being ordered to leave the longtime encampment in New York, Nov. 15, 2011  (Credit: AP/John Minchillo)

Topics:

10. “Deadliest Catch” (Discovery)

The only so-called reality program to make my list, this Discovery Channel program is really a documentary series about the toll taken by relentless physical labor. The Cornelia Marie and its rivals fish icy waters for crab, hoping to up their totals, but the show itself really doesn’t care all that much about who’s ahead and who’s behind. It’s always more interested in the human stories — the most central of which found the Cornelia Marie’s crew struggling to muddle on after the death of Capt. Phil Harris last season. Cable is currently filled with series that desperately want to be “Deadliest Catch” — see “Ice Road Truckers,” “Swamp People,” etc. — but they tend to miss the atmosphere and deep attention to psychology that make this series so special.

Continue Reading
Monday, Dec 19, 2011 6:05 AM UTC2011-12-19T06:05:00Zl, M j, Y g:i A T

Should “Homeland” have quit while it was ahead?

It's hard to imagine the Showtime series topping its debut season -- but a second is in the works anyway.

VIDEO
Moment of truth: Nick Brody (Damian Lewis) wrestles with destiny on the season finale of "Homeland."

Moment of truth: Nick Brody (Damian Lewis) wrestles with destiny on the season finale of "Homeland."  (Credit: Showtime)

Topics:,
The following article contains spoilers for the season finale of "Homeland," season one. Read at your own risk.

Bugs Bunny and Daffy Duck might not seem to belong in a review of a searing cable drama about terrorism, but bear with me, OK? In the climax of “Show Biz Bugs” (1957), in which Bugs and Daffy compete for the right to claim top billing in a show, Daffy decides he’s had enough of being bested by the rabbit and hauls out his trump card, self-immolation. “I must warn those with weak constitutions to leave the theater for this performance,” the duck says, then swallows gasoline, nitroglycerine, gunpowder, uranium and a lit match, and explodes. “That’s terrific, Daffy!” Bugs exclaims from the wings, over thunderous applause. “They loved it! They want more!” “I know, I know,” says Daffy’s ghost, floating toward the rafters. “But I can only do it once!”

Continue Reading

Page 1 of 63 in Matt Zoller Seitz

Other News